Hi G,
I am not sure whether I understood exactly your question. Do you mean an automatic separation of old postings after a certain while in archives and new postings that are directly accessable under the same topic?
We can make automatic archiving. These archives are still searchable over the search function. The only drawback would be that it is less convenient to read online. If you look at some N-system threads about the ND, you will see some archives there at the buttom. Click here:
http://www.contaxinfo.com/cgi-bin/discus/board-auth.cgi?file=/14047/91.html
We tried that for a while although I do not know whether the user is really looking in these archives, or whether he is just asking the same question again just for the convenience. Normally the word "archive" is already a barrier to click on (psychologically). Maybe I am wrong on that point. We just do not want to stress too much the support of the more experienced users by answering always the same questions of new users.
"I have also found that navigating this site has proven a bit chaotic and time consuming"
This is a very intersting point. What exactly did you find in the past chaotic and time consuming while using this forum.
- Can you describe for what you have been looking at that moment in our forum and at Fred's?
- Have you used the search function or did you click through the topics?
- Were you looking for something specific or did you just want to read new messages?
I am asking in that detail to find out where we could improve things. Depending on your desire one structure is better than the other. We have to find out how most of our members are using this forum to evaluate what needs to be improved.
Fred's site is clearly "forcing" its users to visit the site daily. Otherwise you will not be able to keep up with all new postings. I doubt that users are looking what was written 3 days ago as far as I undersood Marc, but Marc can correct me on that if I am wrong at this point. That is why I am a little bit surprised to hear you find Fred's easier to navigate. Or do you mean the bigger buttons etc for navigation, which makes it easier to see and use?
There is also no automatic e-mail notification with the incl. posting as we do. They use similar to Photo.net a case by case notification, which you have to set up individually as soon as a new thread is there.
But maybe most of the user do not care about this e-mail notification? I found it always very convenient since it is a very good compromise between Forum and mailing list - from both worlds the best part. You can read even in the office without the knowledge of your colleages
But also this has to be discussed. Maybe the majority thinks differently.
Regarding the "layout" of our site, there is obviously nothing to discus. I think we all agree unfortunately on that point
But hiring somebody to make a nice layout is expensive (if you do not know how to do it yourself), so we can only improve on that one, if we have more income/ subscribers.