telephoto zoom 80-200 or 70-210

[gillou]

hi,
i am looking infos on these two zooms because i would buy one.
do you know the quality of these lenses ?
thanks

 

[gillou]

hi,
i am looking infos on these two zooms because i would buy one.
do you know the quality of these lenses ?
thanks

maybe the 200mm f/3.5 is better but the zoom is usefull

 

[flatulent1]

I've only used the 80-200, but I'm quite satisfied with it.

 

[gillou]

it appears to be fine. the minimum focus distance of 1 meter is very good.
there is the alternative of the tokina 80-200 f/2.8, heavier but maybe as good.
the contax 70-210 have prices very high.

 

[gillou]

i bought a zeiss 80-200 on ebay, i will try it in few days and let you know.

 

[gillou]

hi,
i have at home the zeiss 80-200mm and the Yashica ML 70-210mm f/4.5. i am very surprised by the yashica one. high definition lens. i will have some morepictures to show in few days.

 

[gillou]

hi,
here under some pictures from contax S2/yashica ML 70-210mm f/4.5. a light bundle, easy to walk with.

 

[gillou]

after several monthes with 3 lenses covering 200mm, it is hard to make a choice. yashica 70-210, zeiss 80-200 and zeiss 200/3.5 are good. usualy i do not like zoom lenses but the zeiss one is sharp. the 200/3.5 have a nice background blur and i am very surprised by the sharpness of the yashica one for a very low price.
the minimum focusing distance of 1m is good for proxyphoto with the CZ 80-200.

 

[dirk]

I would recommend the Zeiss 80-200/4.0. I used it in the analogue days and later with an Olympus E620 and an adapter. Great lens. The 70-210 is an older designs and the Yashica versions not on par with the Contax versions. Since the Contax/Zeiss 80-200 is not that expensive on ebay, I would go for that.

Be aware that it is very long. I had sometimes a hard time to get everything in my camera bag. Also the zooming is something you have to get used to.

I still have my Zeiss 80-200, but I converted it to M42 mount to be able to use it easier with different brands.

Best wishes

 

[gillou]

zeiss lenses are very sharp. the 80-200 zeiss zoom is the good choice. the CZ 200/3.5 seems to be sharper in my opinion. the yashica 70-210mm is a good bargain because is very cheap.
indeed, the CZ 80-200 is very long but it is not an heavy lens.